Japanese 1st Edition marks, era by era
From 2001 until the end of the XY era, most Japanese sets were printed twice: a 1st Edition run first, then an unlimited run (Bulbapedia). Both runs used the same layout, so the two copies of a card have the same picture, text and foil. One small mark, printed only on the 1st Edition copy, tells them apart. Where that mark sits on the card changed from era to era, and this guide shows where to look in each.
The mark
The Japanese mark is a bold "1" standing on a rule over the word EDITION, printed in black and only a few millimetres wide. It is not the stamp that English 1st Edition cards carry: Bulbapedia shows the two side by side (Bulbapedia). The same mark is on every Japanese 1st Edition card, from the first sets to the last.
An unlimited copy has nothing in that spot: there is no unlimited mark. So a card from a set that had both runs is 1st Edition if the mark is there and unlimited if it isn't. Nothing else on the card tells the runs apart, so when the corner is cut off in a photo or hidden by a holder, the edition can't be read.
Which sets have it
The first Japanese sets had no 1st Edition runs (Bulbapedia). The Japanese Base Set, Expansion Pack, was printed twice, but its first printing is told apart another way: its cards have no rarity symbol at the bottom, which is why collectors call it No Rarity. Jungle and the sets after it, through the Neo era, were printed only once (Elite Fourum).
1st Edition runs began with Pokémon VS and Pokémon Web in 2001 and ended with Expansion Pack 20th Anniversary (Bulbapedia). From the Sun & Moon era on, Japanese sets have had no 1st Edition runs (Elite Fourum).
In between, most sets had both runs, and the unlimited run was often the smaller one (Bulbapedia). How much smaller varies a lot from set to set, and each era's section says what collectors report. Some sets had only one run (Elite Fourum):
- Only 1st Edition: Pokémon VS, Red Collection, Dark Rush, Dragon Selection, Spiral Force, Shiny Collection and the concept packs of the XY era (below).
- Only unlimited: Lost Link, Master Deck Build Box EX, the XY Beginning Set, the 20th Anniversary Starter Pack, the Premium Champion Pack, and small tie-in sets such as the McDonald's, PokéPark and movie sets.
Pokémon VS and Pokémon Web
On Pokémon VS and Pokémon Web cards the mark sits at the lower right, just above the card number.
Pokémon VS was printed only in 1st Edition. The one unlimited card is Pryce's Lapras, given away with a magazine (Elite Fourum). Pokémon Web had both runs, in about equal numbers (Elite Fourum).
Example: Surfing Pikachu 025/048.
e-Card sets
On the e-Card sets, Expedition Expansion, The Town on No Map, Wind from the Sea, Split Earth and Mysterious Mountains, the mark also sits at the lower right: just left of the set symbol, above the card number. Beside the set symbol is where early Japanese sets put it (Bulbapedia).
Unlimited copies of the first set, Expedition Expansion, are almost unknown. Only a few non-holo cards have turned up, likely handed out at events or in decks, and an unlimited Ponyta came with a magazine. The four later sets are easier to find unlimited, though still rarer than 1st Edition (Elite Fourum, Elite Fourum).
Example: Pikachu 033/088.
ADV and PCG
From ADV Expansion Pack to Offense and Defense of the Furthest Ends, the mark moved to the lower left. It sits at the start of the card's bottom line, before the short card code (such as 2GP-CL2-LW1) or the copyright line. The World Champions Pack has it in the same place.
Don't use that card code to tell the runs apart. Commons were printed with four different codes and uncommons with two, in both runs (Elite Fourum), so two copies of a card can have different codes whatever their edition. The Pikachu below is an example.
Both runs of these sets are easy to find. The World Champions Pack is the exception: it was sold for only about two weeks, and its unlimited copies are very rare (Elite Fourum).
Example: Pikachu 022/053.
Diamond & Pearl and Platinum
From Space-Time Creation to Advent of Arceus, the mark sits at the lower left, at the bottom of the colored panel just before the copyright line. The ●, ◆ or ★ beside the card number at the lower right is the card's rarity, not an edition mark.
Both runs of these sets are easy to find (Elite Fourum).
Example: Gengar 042/090.
LEGEND (HeartGold & SoulSilver)
On the LEGEND sets, HeartGold Collection and SoulSilver Collection, Reviving Legends and Clash at the Summit, the mark sits at the lower left, left of the copyright line.
The first two sets are almost all 1st Edition: the few unlimited cards collectors report are the three Johto starters, Chikorita, Cyndaquil and Totodile, and some of the LEGEND cards (Elite Fourum, Elite Fourum). Unlimited copies of Reviving Legends and Clash at the Summit exist but are much harder to find than 1st Edition (Elite Fourum). The Steelix and Tyranitar constructed decks were also sold unlimited (Elite Fourum, Elite Fourum), and Lost Link was printed only unlimited.
Example: Psyduck 015/080.
Black & White
From Black Collection and White Collection to Megalo Cannon, the mark sits at the lower left, at the start of the retreat cost's line (にげる).
Unlimited copies of these sets are much rarer than 1st Edition, and most were printed two or three years after the set came out (Elite Fourum). Red Collection, Dark Rush, Dragon Selection, Spiral Force and Shiny Collection were printed only in 1st Edition. Spiral Force's twin, Thunder Knuckle, had an unlimited run (Elite Fourum).
Example: Zebstrika 025/052.
XY
From Collection X and Collection Y to Fever-Burst Fighter and Cruel Traitor, the mark sits where it did in Black & White: at the lower left, at the start of the retreat cost's line, just above the copyright line.
As in Black & White, the unlimited runs came later and are much rarer (Elite Fourum). Blue Shock, Red Flash and Rage of the Broken Heavens were once listed as 1st Edition only, but collectors have since confirmed unlimited copies of them (Elite Fourum).
The six concept packs, from Magma vs Aqua Double Crisis to Expansion Pack 20th Anniversary, had only one run each. All of them were printed only in 1st Edition except the fourth, the Premium Champion Pack, which was printed only unlimited (Elite Fourum). The others are Legendary Shine Collection, PokéKyun Collection and Mythical & Legendary Dream Shine Collection.
Example: Clefairy 065/096.
Expansion Pack 20th Anniversary
The last concept pack, Expansion Pack 20th Anniversary, is laid out differently from the rest of the XY era, so its mark has a place of its own: at the lower left, at the start of the bottom line, in front of the illustrator's name. Every copy is 1st Edition: the set had no unlimited run (Elite Fourum).
Example: Charizard 011/087.
Sun & Moon onward
Japanese sets stopped having 1st Edition runs with the Sun & Moon era (Elite Fourum), so a Japanese card from a later set has no mark to look for.
The mark can still turn up on later reprints of older cards. The 25th Anniversary Creatures Deck, the History Gate Deck that Creatures gave its staff and the game's illustrators at the end of 2021, reprints a card from each year of the game, and the ones taken from 1st Edition cards keep the mark: its Professor Oak's Hint has it at the lower left, as on Expansion Pack 20th Anniversary (Creatures, Pokumon).
Reading photos and listings
- Look at the corner, not the label. A listing's photo may not show the copy on offer: collectors have found sellers using one stock photo of an unlimited card for 1st Edition copies, and shops that send either edition at random (Elite Fourum). A listing's title can be wrong about the edition too, so read the mark in the photo before trusting it.
- Small pictures hide it. On a scan a few hundred pixels wide the mark is only a few pixels across. On dark holo cards it can vanish into the foil, so look at the largest photo there is.
- A hidden corner is an unknown edition. If a sleeve, a holder or the photo's edge covers the corner where the mark would be, the photo can't say which run the card is from.
Sources
- Bulbapedia: 1st Edition (TCG)
- Elite Fourum: 1st Edition Timeline: Lets Iron it Out
- Elite Fourum: Is Unlimited more rare than 1st Ed. in Japanese?
- Elite Fourum: Sets and Languages Compilation Overview List
- Elite Fourum: Unlimited edition of Japanese sets during the XY era
- Creatures Inc.: HISTORY GATE DECK
- Pokumon: Professor Oak's Hint 084/087, 25th Anniversary Creatures Corporate History Deck
- Card photos: PriceCharting